Compare Controls: Inquiry v Action

Similarity

Realist v Idealist perspectives define the oscillating duality for both PH'1-Decision methods and PH'2-Research methods. Review the decision method duality.

Differences in the use of the perspective have required qualifiers:

• for realism: practical realism (PH'1) and scientific realism (PH'2).
• for idealism: functional idealism (PH'1) and epistemic idealism (PH'2).

Other similarities are more striking. As the diagram below shows, the upper 5 methods (L'3 to L'7) in the two Typologies have very similar core qualities, and even similar names (identical in one case). Of course, these qualities are used differently because they have to serve different primal needs: achievement (for PH'1) and knowledge (for PH'2).

ClosedCf. Other Domains

Comparison of the idealism-realism duality as applied in the Action and the Inquiry Domains.

Differences

The requirements of the two Domains are diametrically opposite, and the difference between these two Typologies lies in what needs to dominate:

In the case of the Action Domain, the concern is successful performance for achievement. So ideas demand reality be altered to accord with them. Ideas must be in the driving seat because we desire or need reality to alter in line with our values and objectives.

In the case of the Inquiry Domain, the concern is to maximize the certainty of knowledge. So ideas here should accord with reality as it is taken to be. Realism must be in the driving seat, because we desire or need our ideas (findings, theories) to correspond as closely as possible to reality, whatever that may be.

From the diagram, it is evident that the odd-numbered levels are dominant because they are in the majority and found both at the very top and very bottom of the hierarchy. Dominance is most apparent in the lowest two levels which, unlike the others, are not similar within the two Domains.

L'1 in each Domain appears to be fundamental, and its equivalent in the other Domain is L'2. However, the significance of the L'2 position suggests considerable interaction.

For Decisions:
setting purposes-L'1
needs to be shaped and guided by using information-L'2.

For Research:
accumulating facts-L'1 needs to be shaped and guided by systematic ratiocination-L'2.

This analysis is jumping ahead of itself: these methods cannot be assumed to shape and guide each other within a person, because methods are independent incommensurable entities that oppose each other. However, the values intrinsic to those methods, as revealed in the Spiral analysis, can coexist and do reveal direct influences between methods: especially between L'1 and L'2.
ClosedMore.

Primary Hierarchy Oscillation

The Principal Typology hierarchy parallels the Primary Hierarchy (i.e. L'1 has links to L1, L'2 to L2 &c.), so we might expect to find similar or related differences in the oscillating duality in PH1-Action and PH2-Inquiry.

The Table below shows the oscillation pattern for these two Primary Hierarchies as recently developed in an Architecture Room investigation.

ACTION-PH1 PH1 Oscillation L PH2 Oscillation INQUIRY-
PH2
Spontaneity Internal
experience
7 Subjective:
personal control
Wonder
Choice External
pressures
6 Objective:
social control
Judgement
Intervention Internal
appraisal
5 Subjective:
personal control
Relation
Response External
instigation
4 Objective:
social control
Measurement
Technique Internal
system
3 Subjective:
personal control
Comparison
Procedure External
demand
2 Objective:
social control
Concept
Movement (bodily) Internal
volition
1 Subjective:
personal control
Data

However, our expectation is confounded. In the Principal Typologies, odd levels in PH'1 are similar in perspective to even levels in PH'2 (and vice versa), but the above Table reveals a different picture: 

  • Odd-numbered levels in both PH1 and PH2 align with an internal control, which we might otherwise view as underpinning an idealist position.
  • Even-numbered levels in both PH1 and PH2 align with an external control, which we might otherwise view as underpinning a realist position.

Conclusion: Oscillation in Principal Typologies is different in nature from oscillation in Primary Hierarchies.


Originally drafted: 17-Apr-2015. Last amended: 30-Apr-2022.