Consciousness & Endeavour

The «Hard» Question

Q: Why do we possess consciousness?

A:Closed Consciousness is necessary for complex endeavours or simple endeavours that involve doing something new. These endeavours were the basis of our evolutionary competitive advantage and currently drive social change.

Classic sculpture: Rodin's "Thinker"

Consciousness is the current focus of much scientific debate and research—while endeavour, our biological competitive advantage, is not. Human consciousness, in the sense of our reflective awareness, is viewed here as an essential component of endeavour. So studying consciousness in isolation is to take it out of its natural setting.
ClosedMore

Isolated study leads to a focus on redness (the favourite of philosophers) or on trivial judgements (like calculations) or simple feelings (like anger)—all taken utterly out of context.

This neglect of a human context shows up painfully in brain MRI studies of subjects asked to consider a moral dilemma: e.g. in what is known as «trolleyology»Link to external website the experimenter says something like the following to a subject (you):Closed Five people are tied up on a railway track, with a runaway trolley heading for them. You are in the train yard next to a lever. If you pull the lever, the trolley will switch to another track—where just one person is tied up. You have only two options: (1) Do nothing, and the trolley kills five people. (2) Pull the lever, and it kills one person. Which is the correct choice?

The simple fact is that if you are inside that MRI machine, you are not subject to any moral dilemma at all. Your endeavour is about helping a researcher do a study. Making an artificial moral dilemma the content of the study gives superficial plausibility at the price of deep falsity—even if "everyone in cognitive neuroscience does it."

Many or most psychological lab studies have this failing. They define a situation but not an endeavour. Yet, if the brain has evolved for endeavours as I believe it has, then to study it out of its natural habitat is liable to lead to wrong conclusions.

In the Taxonomy, alertness (rather than sleep or coma) is assumed, so the degree of consciousness is not relevant. All attention is given to what can come into awareness as part of a classification effort. So, the Taxonomy does not examine the «how» aspects of consciousness (i.e. how represented in the brain), but the «what» i.e. mental experiences.

No position is taken on the 'hard' question of consciousnessLink to external website for neuroscience and philosophy. However, the Taxonomy has generated a variety of reasonable conjectures that lend themselves to neuroscientific study. To benefit from this website, these conjectures are far less important than the Taxonomy itself.

The Role of Consciousness

Q: If consciousness is needed for endeavour, what role does it play?

A:Closed Our minds bring elements of endeavour into awareness in order to evaluate them (e.g. our purpose, our willingness, what is involved &c.) and to check and guide its progress in practice over time (e.g. with information, through decisions &c.)

Achievement itself does not require conscious awareness. If you drive often to work, you can safely arrive there without consciously attending to every action. But try driving to a place that you have never visited before: you pore over maps, use a GPS, slow down to peer at road signs. You are fully aware during your trip because you must consciously sense and think to arrive safely.

So purpose (a taxonomic element) itself is not part of consciousness, but it can be brought into consciousness (as an idea) if it is part of an endeavour. An action is not necessarily in consciousness either, but it can be experienced in advance (as an image) and while it is occurring (as sensations). There are other forms of experience, each with their own contribution to endeavour. The central element of conscious experience generated by the mind is an inner continuity and coherence that we call «the self». The «sense of self» is what makes me experience my endeavour as mine, and you experience yours as yours.

ClosedWhat about Pure Experience?

Only through our mental experience can we be aware of elements of endeavour so as to share and evaluate them. The Taxonomy was initially envisaged as covering the human elements of endeavour (hence: THEE). But it could have been referred to as a Taxonomy of Endeavour Elements in Awareness (TEEA), or a Taxonomy of Experienced Personal Functioning (TEPF).

ClosedAre Animals Conscious?

Scientists have long tended to deny that animals are conscious, a view at odds with the everyday observations of every dog and horse owners. That view is shifting. Now birds and even fish and invertebrates (like cephalopods, crustaceans and insects) are believed to have a form of consciousness.

Here is a pertinent quote from Charles Darwin in his The Descent of Man written over 150 years ago:
"It has, I think, now been shewn that man and the higher animals, especially the primates, have some few instincts in common. All have the same senses, intuitions, and sensations,- similar passions, affections, and emotions, even the more complex ones, such as jealousy, suspicion, emulation, gratitude, and magnanimity; they practise deceit and are revengeful; they are sometimes susceptible to ridicule, and even have a sense of humour; they feel wonder and curiosity; they possess the same faculties of imitation, attention, deliberation, choice, memory, imagination, the association of ideas, and reason, though in very different degrees. The individuals of the same species graduate in intellect from absolute imbecility to high excellence."

Research Strategy

This research project started by identifying elements in endeavour to help people who were confused about what they were doing. Once the taxonomic architecture was established, it became possible to trace it back to biological properties of the organism—and to ask which neural circuits or brain states might support such structures.

The taxonomy elements are observable. Observations can be replicated and errors corrected. Taxonomic regularities and principles are checkable. By contrast, the biological infrastructure is currently conjectural. These conjectures need testing, which is a more complex process involving methods of neurophysiology or comparative biology.


Originally posted: 14-Jan-2014. Last Updated: 7-Nov-2026.