Common Scientific Questions

ClosedIs THEE new?

THEE as an ordered unified whole is new, and some ideas may well be new for you. Nevertheless, the frameworks contain virtually no new observations or concepts. Many of its elements are familiar from everyday observations, perennial wisdom, or social science research. Those professions dedicated to self-help, personal advice, management consulting and organizational development generally use taxonomic principles without knowing it.

At present, crucial taxonomic observations are often barely accessible to scientists because they are distributed very widely in diverse and distinct disciplines and practices. This leads to unnecessary misunderstandings, duplications, and recycling of old findings with new names.

ClosedWhere is the evidence?

On this website, in life all around you, in your head, and in the literature.

However, remember that evidence typically relates to a conjecture. The Taxonomy is not itself a conjecture:  it is a pattern found in impartial observations. This pattern can be checked.

You can independently examine the evidence for any specific observation or taxonomic formulation or ordering. I would encourage you (and others) to do so.

ClosedHow do I evaluate a taxonomic framework?

Criteria relevant in evaluating Frameworks include correspondence, precision, simplicity, applicability, fertility, elegance, illumination, problem resolution, prediction, and structural integrity.

The brain tends to prefer wholes to details, and concepts to things. However, a taxonomy is necessarily about details and things. So expect it to feel strange. We take most details of living and working for granted, and do not usually reflect on our own functioning in a precise or scientific way.

ClosedIs the taxonomy complete?

THEE is the result of an arduous, uncertain voyage to a previously undreamed-of destination: a comprehensive specification of the forms of personal and social existence. But the studies have only been pursued over a few decades: how can it be complete at this point?

Many of the more fundamental parts have been clarified. However, despite recognition and development of many frameworks within the various Domains, many more remain to be identified and formulated.

It is also unlikely that the architecture of THEE is fully worked out.

ClosedCan social science reveal taxonomic frameworks?

Not in the way it currently functions. However, it can and should explain the frameworks. The problem is that academic disciplines start with concepts, not with brute observations. Experiments are set up using concepts. Experimenters select and organize observations that operationalize those concepts. Researchers then manipulate these concept-drenched observations to test hypotheses within established theories.

Due to the limitations intrinsic to social science disciplines, increasing numbers of researchers in para-academic institutions are being formed to deal with practical themes and social problems, and there are also innovative consultancies. These efforts typically lead to the (re-)discovery of parts of THEE. See inquiry differences tabulated here.

ClosedCan conventional researchers investigate taxonomic findings?

Yes: they can and they should. Any taxonomy, including this one, is an objectivist product. It is a typical result of scientific enterprise. It differs from usual research in studying subjectively determined realities, products of awareness or consciousness, not the physical world. Its taxonomic categories (elements) could and should be viewed as concepts for research purposes. Frameworks can be used to develop meaningful hypotheses.

ClosedHow are genuinely new observations, ideas or models handled?

Sensibly: by location within the Taxonomy as known, or by offering the potential for an expansion of taxonomic understanding.

Intelligent social scientists, popular writers and reflective practitioners regularly claim to make new observations and offer new design insights. Mostly these new ideas are as old as the hills. The value of such work stems from these old ideas not being given sufficient attention. They therefore deserve re-articulation in a modern voice. At other times, the new model is a combination of old ideas.

However, there have been genuinely new ideas and models. Some of these have led to the elaboration of previously undiscovered or undeveloped frameworks. For example, see how I handled the 'core group' idea of Art Kleiner. Another example is appreciative inquiryLink to external website, which is currently being located within the Taxonomy.

ClosedHas AI research attempted to model psychosocial reality?


Originally posted: May 2010; Last updated: 29-Jan-2015