Auspices for the Methods

The Distinction

Personal stability is a concern and responsibility of each person, but it is also a natural concern of the surrounding group or community. After all, personal disruption can wreak social havoc and personal balance fosters group goals and helps meet broader social needs.

The extreme v central distinction used in the initial plotting of the methods generates two concentric circles. These reveal sets of methods operating under two different auspices.

Inner circle methods (L'3-sensitive, L'6, L'4, L'1) are ultimately under social auspices and receive much social guidance, rulings, support and, in extremis, control.
Outer circle methods (L'3-empathic, L'7, L'5) are ultimately under personal auspices and may garner either social support or opposition.

Inner Circle: Social Auspices

The inner circle traces out methods, i.e. existences, in which self-stabilization is routinely shaped and bolstered by the relevant social environment as explained below.

Centrifugal tendencies of the central decison methods. The more extreme are viewed as more sophisticated.

Emotional-sensitive existence occurs under social auspices because the relevant wider society institutes conventions and expectations for feelings and how they should be handled. In many cultures, sympathetic responses like comfort, encouragement, praise, or help may be promptly provided by anyone with whom you happen to be dealing with at the time. Emotional responses that do not fall within cultural expectations lead to disapproval or rejection.
Social existence occurs under social auspices almost by definition. Groups organize and set rules for the participation of their members. Communities determine values and needs. So projects that do not fit are blocked or suffer financially, and participation may lead to a loss of respect and status. Groups have ways to express gratitude and award honours for conformity, and ways to punish, extrude, boycott and exile dissidents.
Individual existence occurs under social auspices because self-esteem is most easily sustained when others with whom you regularly associate also value you and your work. Self-respect and self-acceptance are difficult to maintain unless they are unequivocally reflected by respect and acceptance from relevant groups. Sufficient continuous rejection can lead to suicide.
Sensory existence occurs under social auspices because circles and networks are far more powerful than any single member. They evolve and sustain conventions and events which provide the desired sensory gratifications as well as the necessary personal affirmation and validation. Examples: When you 'follow' or 'like' someone in social media, they will often follow/like you back; everyone in an informal bridge-playing circle takes turns in hosting bridge evenings with food and wine; a circle may have a custom of birthday celebrations for its members.

Outer Circle: Personal Auspices

The outer circle traces out methods, i.e. existences, in which personal effort is the basis of stabilization, regardless of social pressures. Certain distinguishing features can be noted:

These methods may be valued, devalued or ignored in any particular social environment. For adherents, life is much easier where they are valued.
Existence via these methods are intrinsically not readily subject to social rules or pressures.
These existences are noticeably more difficult to sustain than those on the inner circle.
Because the methods are more specialized and may require more determination, personalized reinforcement and guidance is often sought.

Emotional-empathic existence occurs under personal auspices because deep emotional understanding relates to the inner tolerance of differing perspectives and the capacity to share pains and joys. These are matters about which the social environment has no say. In case of relationship difficulties or over-involvement, discussion with a colleague or common friend who is also empathic may be useful.
Vital existence occurs under personal auspices because physical exercise, sport and health-care are naturally a matter of self-responsibility. The surrounding culture or workplace may be more or less supportive. The assistance of a professional trainer is commonly sought, even (or especially) by natural sports-persons to get educated about what is healthy, to strengthen discipline and to support motivation.
Transpersonal existence occurs under personal auspices because faith and spiritual disciplines are intrinsically private and independent of what others do or think. The dominant religion in the wider community may support, but it usually disapproves sensing a loss of control. Because of the difficulties and uncertainties surrounding this method, it is common to seek the encouragement and guidance of a spiritual master, guru or transpersonal counsellor.
Relational existence occurs under personal auspices because cultivating meaningful relationships is ultimately a private matter for the persons concerned. Wider society usually exerts pressure to follow conventions which may be antithetical in particular cases: stories of lovers overcoming family or group opposition are legion. Any relationship can run into difficulties, and advice is then commonly sought from another intimate.
Specialist relationship counsellors typically focus on assisting those who are not primarily relational-L'5 or who suffer from specific psychological problems.

The next step is to recognize differences in the two diagonal sets.

Originally posted: 15-Oct-2014. Last updated: 19-Dec-2014.

All posted material is part of a scientific project and should be regarded as provisional. Visitors are encouraged to think through the topics and propositions for themselves. Copyright © Warren Kinston 2009-2016.
All Rights Reserved.